Hero Image

Top Orthopedic Surgeons in 2025: Who They Are and How to Choose the Right One

Orthopedic surgeons play a vital role in treating bone, joint, ligament, and muscle conditions—from chronic arthritis and sports injuries to full joint replacements.

But with hundreds of qualified professionals across the U.S., how do you find the top orthopedic surgeons who truly stand out?

This guide walks you through what sets the best apart, how to evaluate surgeons in your area, and highlights of some of the most respected orthopedic specialists in the country.

What Makes an Orthopedic Surgeon “Top-Rated”?

While many orthopedic doctors are board-certified and skilled, the top-tier surgeons tend to have:

  • Fellowship training in a subspecialty (e.g., sports medicine, joint replacement, spine)
  • A strong track record of surgical outcomes
  • Hospital affiliations with top-rated medical centers
  • Positive patient reviews and peer recommendations
  • Participation in clinical research or published studies

They also demonstrate strong communication skills and involve patients in shared decision-making.

Top-Ranked Orthopedic Subspecialties

Orthopedic care includes a wide range of subspecialties, and the best surgeon for you depends on your condition. If you're seeking a joint replacement, look for a high-volume surgeon with a low complication rate who specializes in hip, knee, or shoulder implants. For sports medicine issues such as ACL repairs, meniscus tears, or rotator cuff injuries, the top surgeons are those skilled in minimally invasive techniques and often work with athletes. If you’re dealing with spine conditions, top spine surgeons typically offer a multidisciplinary approach to pain management and perform procedures like disc replacement or spinal fusion. For pediatric orthopedic care, leading specialists treat conditions like scoliosis, clubfoot, or limb deformities and are highly experienced with growing children and developmental factors. Finally, for hand and wrist conditions such as carpal tunnel syndrome or fractures, the best surgeons are often those with advanced microsurgical skills and a strong focus on post-operative rehabilitation.

Top Orthopedic Surgeons in the U.S. (2025)

While excellence exists in every region, here are some nationally recognized orthopedic specialists:

1. Dr. Bryan Kelly – HSS, New York

  • Specialty: Sports medicine, hip preservation
  • Why he’s top-rated: Chief of Surgery at Hospital for Special Surgery (ranked #1 in orthopedics by U.S. News)
  • Notable work: Team physician for professional athletes

2. Dr. James Andrews – Andrews Institute, Florida

  • Specialty: Sports injuries
  • Why he’s top-rated: Legendary in orthopedic sports medicine; treated countless NFL and MLB stars
  • Reputation: Pioneer of modern sports injury treatment

3. Dr. Steven Haas – HSS, New York

  • Specialty: Knee and hip replacement
  • Why he’s top-rated: Innovator in minimally invasive joint replacements and rapid recovery protocols

4. Dr. Kevin Bozic – Dell Medical School, Texas

  • Specialty: Joint reconstruction
  • Why he’s top-rated: National leader in value-based orthopedic care, author of numerous orthopedic outcomes studies

5. Dr. Serena Hu – Stanford Medicine, California

  • Specialty: Spine surgery
  • Why she’s top-rated: One of the nation’s top female spine surgeons, known for advanced spine alignment techniques

How to Find the Best Orthopedic Surgeon Near You

Even if you’re not near a nationally known specialist, here’s how to locate top local talent:

  1. Start with a board-certified surgeon listed on AAOS.org.
  2. Look for hospital affiliations with top-rated orthopedic programs.
  3. Read verified patient reviews on Healthgrades, Zocdoc, or Google.
  4. Ask your primary doctor or physical therapist for referrals.
  5. Verify insurance coverage, including Medicare or VA if applicable.

Questions to Ask Before Choosing Your Surgeon

  • How many times have you performed this surgery?
  • What are the complication and success rates?
  • What is the typical recovery timeline?
  • Are you fellowship-trained in this area?
  • What is your follow-up and rehab process?

Final Thoughts: Your Joint Health Deserves the Best

Finding the right orthopedic surgeon is a major step toward regaining mobility and quality of life. Whether you’re seeking a total joint replacement or a minimally invasive procedure, choose a specialist who combines technical excellence with clear communication and compassion.

With the right support team, you can move forward confidently—literally and figuratively.

Sources